Is this really acceptable?

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/7030267.stm

What do you think about this? I cant help but feel its a bit wrong how would you feel about carrying your Father in laws baby and then technically giving birth to your husbands brother!

oh i think its wrong,but then if thats what they want then so b i,
but havin a son as ur half brother x

Thats just weird, i could never do that. Its just not right!!!

is that just not like say a sister donating an egg for another sister? The man says he doesnt have a brother, so thats why his father was chosen. Its just sperm at the end of the day, its not like she will be having sex with her father in law! I dont really see a problem with it to be honest, i think its a lovely thing for a 72 year old man to do for his family....but i wouldnt go down that route myself!

yeah as much as i wouldnt personally choose this myself i can see why the man is doin it x

im same as max can see why they r doing it but wouldnt want to do it myself either x

I think its a better idea than getting sperm from some random source. at least the baby will have similar DNA to its"father" and they know the medical history of both sides. As far as the childs well being goes, i'd say it was a fairly good idea.

Why wouldn't it be acceptable. About 1 year ago I actually looked after a women in labour who already had 4 children of her own and was carrying a fifth child whom she was going to give to her sister because the sister couldn't have children.It all depends on a persons cultural and ethical beliefs.Persnally I don't think their is anything wrong with this.